Between the two, which one would you prefer?

Last Sunday night, I went to the Great Falls and took the above shot. 

It was 20 min after sunset. But already quite dark. 

I did some light painting the foreground rocks with flashlight.

--

Now I lightened up the scene for the foreground rocks. 

The following is the result. Which between these two is better choice?

Better yet... I have just made one between the above two... 

Any suggestions?

Thanks. 

Looking forward to meeting you all this Friday at the Great Falls, MD.

Kee Woo Rhee